After reading the texts, the one that stood out the most in
connection to the topic of my blog was Place and Placelessness, Edward Relph”. This text goes through the main points with
some self-interpretation of what Relph was saying in this text and points out
where people in the past have misinterpreted the text that Relph wrote. The way this text is written makes the reader
to do his or her own interpretation of what was written. By doing this, it made the concepts that were
discussed impact me more, because I was forced in some sections to come to my
conclusions about what this text was saying and also what Relph was saying in
his original text. One of the instences
where is occurred was when the author starts talking about insideness and
outsideness that is connected to my blog topic about physically entering
interpreting a space. “Relph suggests
that the more profoundly inside a place a person feels, the stronger will be
his or her identity with that place (p. 45). This can be physical but also mental
insideness a person can feel about the space.
In the physical realm a person being able to enter a building, plaza, or
empty lot can bring them a deeper understanding of what the designer wanted to
make you feel or what potential the empty lot has for a dynamic
experience. I was able to experience
this when I went to Chicago this past week and went to Frank Lloyd Wright’s
Home and Studio for the first time. I
had seen pictures and read descriptions of what the experience of the space was
but it was different and inspiring to be able to walk through the different
rooms and see how Wright wanted the people who walked through his house to
experience it. The experience was the
most powerful in the playroom and main entertaining room in the house. In this room, I was able to experience the
differing heights and how Wright wanted people to move and see each wall and
what was on each wall. I feel that the
deep understanding that Wright had about his architecture can be drawn from
when staring and moving through a design process. I believe that Wright had what Relph would
call “existential insideness” which is “a situation of deep, unself-conscious
immersion in place and the experience most people know when they are at home in
their own community and region” (p. 45).
This feeling was created inside Wrights home where he created a micro
community and region that he had designed every part. This deep immersion and sense of home is what
is possible to achieve in every building that is designed but is impossible to
achieve without being able to go the space and understand the community and
what will deepen the sense of home. The
sense of home goes beyond residential buildings though, a commercial building
where people go the work every day must also make those people feel part of a
region of community. By being able to go
to Chicago this past week, I feel that my design of museum will deepen the
identity of the community and buildings that surround it.
P. Hubbard, R. Kitchen. G. Vallentine. (2008). Place and
Placessness, Edward Relph. Key Texts in
Human Geography (43-51). London:
Sage
I think it's very true that the most important part can be experiencing the space for yourself in the scale it was intended. If you had to decide between one or the other would you rather have;
ReplyDeletea) plans/section/elevations
b) the space itself
Which do you think would be better for transferring ideas or concepts to your own work?
Look forward to more of you posts.
-nick
I would like to look at the plans/sections/elevations before I go and see the space itself. I would rather go to the space then look at a perspective of the space because that is the closest to giving the same experience as being there. The difference is being able to look around and look at everything rather than only being able to look in one direction. Maybe if I could look at a space in VR that might fill my need to physically go to the space.
ReplyDeleteHope that the urban design theories discussed in this module allow you to see cities as unfinished products and their forms are the physical manifestation of the society that keep on evolving overtime.
ReplyDelete